This reminds me of a rather foolish person who sat in #defocus, attempting to debate that buying an iPod was pointless if you didn’t buy music from the iTunes Music store. His logic was broken and he contradicted his own points left and right. He brought up the question: How will you stop piracy without DRM? Now, this person was annoying everyone all to hell, first with the “Paying for EFNet channels” and then the “iPods are useless without the iTunes Store or an FM Tuner”. But the question still remains, how will you stop piracy without DRM?
The answer is simple. Nobody smart likes DRM, therefore they will not buy it, thus not supporting the store that is offering it. Eventually, enough people won’t buy from this store, and the store’s finances will falter if the company behind the store does not have another source of venue. But that still doesn’t answer the question, how will you stop piracy without DRM?
If you take away DRM and remove the leash off of the music they purchase, there will still be the same amount of piracy as exists today. This is because piracy will never die. It can’t die, because the system is too large. In order to stop piracy, you would have to jail or fine a great percentage of Earth’s population. But why would you want to do that?
That answer is also simple, because without the veil that piracy is bad enough to sue for 900k over 14 songs, its because the record labels want to sit on their fat paychecks and not have to worry about living expenses. Sounds good, huh? Out of all the money you spend to buy an album from a physical store, only 23% is given to the artist. So what happens to the other 77%?
The other 77% is put into the record label’s bank to pay its workers and keep them living in the high life, because who doesn’t like living off of others sweat and blood. Its the main principal of taxes. So back to the question. What happens if you take DRM and throw it out the window? The consumer will buy more of the product and the record industry will be pissed because they can’t remake money off of things we already paid for. So lets introduce a new variable to the equation. Say a large group of artists producing out of their own homes, or studio release an independently labeled album. They do all of the marketing and get 100% of the profit. So how’s this work?
Its simple, the artist runs everything, and there is no middle man sapping all of the income. What people fail to see is that this is already proliferating on private torrent trackers and public ones as well. So what does the record label do? Nothing, naturally. They can’t. The artists aren’t bound by any contracts in the first place, but the record industry can try. They will most likely bribe the new artists or try to recruit them in some way, which will fail for strong independent artists.
In the bitter end, there is no end to piracy because it has been around for hundreds of years and will never be stopped. If you remove DRM, it will still be the same, because even if another store is offering DRM encrusted music, chances are your local shop that sells music isn’t.